MGIC Investment (MTG) vs Selective Insurance Group (SIGI)
Head-to-head comparison of performance, valuation, growth, profitability and dividends. Prices delayed 15 minutes; data as of Oct 8, 2026.
Summary
MGIC Investment (MTG) has outperformed Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) over the past year, gaining 3.3% versus a gain of 1.0%. Over five years, MTG leads with a +70.3% price change compared with +8.3% for SIGI. MGIC Investment is the larger company by market cap ($5.72 billion vs $5.07 billion), about 1.1 times the size, while Selective Insurance Group is growing revenue faster (+9.8% vs +0.5%).
On valuation, MGIC Investment trades at a lower forward P/E (8.0x vs 9.7x for Selective Insurance Group). MGIC Investment offers the higher dividend yield (2.15% vs 1.96%). MGIC Investment converts more of its revenue into profit, with a net margin of 60.8% versus 8.7%.
Summary generated from market data by MetaCap's automated system. Methodology
Relative performance
Percent change in share price from the first common trading day shown; excludes dividends.
Head-to-head
| Metric | MTG | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Share price | $27.87 | $85.13 |
| Market cap | $5.72B | $5.07B |
| 1-day change | +2.96% | +1.57% |
| YTD return | -4.62% | +1.74% |
| 1-year return | +3.30% | +1.03% |
| 5-year return | +70.25% | +8.34% |
| P/E ratio (TTM) | 8.71 | 10.56 |
| Forward P/E | 8.00 | 9.68 |
| EPS (TTM) | $3.20 | $8.06 |
| Dividend yield | 2.15% | 1.96% |
| Annual dividend | $0.60 | $1.67 |
| Revenue (latest FY) | $1.21B | $5.34B |
| Revenue growth (YoY) | +0.49% | +9.78% |
| Net income (latest FY) | $738.35M | $466.41M |
| Net margin | 60.84% | 8.74% |
| 52-week high | $31.89 | $100.40 |
| 52-week low | $24.69 | $72.78 |
| Distance from 52-week high | -12.61% | -15.21% |
| Analyst consensus | hold | hold |
| Avg. price target upside | +12.67% | +19.65% |
| Average volume | 2.02M | 477.57K |
| Shares outstanding | 205.12M | 59.57M |
| Employees | 542 | 2,800 |
| Sector | Finance | Finance |
| Industry | Property-Casualty Insurers | Property-Casualty Insurers |
Highlighted cells mark the higher value for growth, returns, margins and yield, and the lower value for P/E ratios. Highlighting is a mechanical comparison, not a recommendation.
Key differences
- MGIC Investment is more profitable, keeping 60.8 cents of every revenue dollar as net income versus 8.7 cents for Selective Insurance Group.
- Selective Insurance Group grew revenue faster in its latest fiscal year (+9.78% vs +0.49%).
About MGIC Investment
MTG stock →MGIC Investment Corporation, through its subsidiaries, provides private mortgage insurance, other mortgage credit risk management solutions, and ancillary services in the United States, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and Guam. The company offers primary insurance that provides mortgage default protection on individual loans, as well as covers unpaid loan principal, delinquent interest, and various expenses associated with the default and subsequent foreclosure on the mortgage or sale of the underlying property.
Finance · Property-Casualty Insurers · 542 employees
About Selective Insurance Group
SIGI stock →Selective Insurance Group, Inc., together with its subsidiaries, provides insurance products and services in the United States. The company operates through four segments: Standard Commercial Lines, Standard Personal Lines, E&S Lines, and Investments.
Finance · Property-Casualty Insurers · 2,800 employees
MTG vs SIGI FAQ
Which is bigger, MGIC Investment or Selective Insurance Group?
MGIC Investment (MTG) is larger, with a market capitalization of $5.72B compared with $5.07B for Selective Insurance Group (SIGI).
Which stock has performed better over the past year, MTG or SIGI?
MTG returned +3.30% over the past 12 months, compared with +1.03% for SIGI (price return, excluding dividends). Past performance does not predict future results.
Which has the lower P/E ratio, MTG or SIGI?
MTG has the lower trailing P/E at 8.7, versus 10.6 for SIGI. A lower P/E is not by itself a sign of a better investment; it can reflect slower expected growth or higher risk.
Which pays a higher dividend, MGIC Investment or Selective Insurance Group?
MGIC Investment has the higher yield at 2.15%, compared with 1.96% for Selective Insurance Group.
Are MGIC Investment and Selective Insurance Group in the same industry?
Yes. Both are classified in the Property-Casualty Insurers industry within the Finance sector.